Skip to content 
If you’re a parent with a child who is currently facing criminal charges, the possibility of your teenager being tried as an adult can be an unsettling thought. Understanding the fundamental differences between the juvenile and adult court systems is essential. In California, minors under the age of 18 typically go through the juvenile court system, whereas individuals who are 18 years or older are prosecuted in the adult court system.
A significant distinction between these two systems lies in their approach to handling offenses. The juvenile court system emphasizes rehabilitation aimed at helping young offenders overcome personal challenges, while the adult court system focuses primarily on punishment for the crime committed. This duality exists because society believes that minors should be treated with more emphasis on support rather than solely on legal consequences.
Understanding Juvenile Crime
What Constitutes a Crime?
A “crime” is defined as any act prohibited by law. In the context of juveniles, common examples of crimes include:
- Drug possession
- Shoplifting
- Vandalism
- Driving under the influence (DUI)
- Auto theft
- Burglary of a residence
- Assault
- Rape
- Trespassing
Classification of Crimes
Crimes, whether committed by minors or adults, are classified into different categories: infractions, misdemeanors, and felonies. This classification applies equally to juveniles in California. Here’s a brief overview of each category:
- Infractions: The least serious offenses, often resulting in fines.
- Misdemeanors: More serious offenses that can lead to jail time and fines.
- Felonies: The most severe crimes, which carry longer prison sentences and significant consequences.
When Are Juveniles Tried as Adults?
Key Factors Leading to Adult Prosecution
In some cases, juveniles may be charged as adults. Generally, this occurs when a juvenile commits a serious violent felony or has a history of criminal behavior without signs of rehabilitation. Here are some examples:
- Serious violent crimes like murder or armed robbery.
- Repeated offenses showing a pattern of criminality.
Age Considerations in California
In California, juveniles as young as 14 can face prosecution in the adult court system. Moreover, if convicted, individuals aged 16 or older can be sentenced to prison. Understanding these age criteria is crucial for parents seeking legal help for their children.
The Impact of Court Decisions
Differences in Court Proceedings
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, a juvenile who is arrested for an ‘adult’ offense may be adjudicated in either juvenile or adult court. The outcome can have significant implications:
- If convicted, juveniles may be placed in either a county or state correctional facility or returned to their community.
- Incarceration might involve placement with other juveniles or adults, depending on the circumstance.
Consequences of Adult Prosecution
In contrast to adults charged with similar offenses, who are tried specifically in adult court and face incarceration with other adults, young offenders have slightly different proceedings designed to consider their developmental stage.
Seeking Legal Assistance
If your child is facing serious criminal charges in the East Bay area, it’s crucial to seek experienced legal counsel tailored to juvenile law. The Law Offices of Nabiel C. Ahmed, located in Oakland, California, specializes in Criminal Defense and understands the complexities of juvenile cases.
To learn more about the specific legal options available to you and your child, do not hesitate to contact us. It’s vital to be well-informed and prepared during this challenging time.
For expert legal representation in Oakland, California, contact the Law Offices of Nabiel C. Ahmed today at 510-576-5544 to discuss your situation further.
Listen on Spotify
